The Polite Revolution
By JOHN IBBITSON
Saturday, October 22, 2005 Posted at 2:00 AM EDT
From Saturday's Globe and Mail
Everyone knows that ours is a deeply troubled land.
Just ask any nationalist from Quebec or pseudo-separatist from Newfoundland. You can waste an entire morning listening to an aggrieved Albertan recite a litany of complaints about the Perfidious Centre. And Ontario? Don't get them started on horizontal transfers and the fiscal imbalance.
Canada doesn't work because it is too much like the United States. Or maybe it's because it is not enough like the United States. The federal government is powerful, domineering and distant. No, the federal government is so weak it can't hold the country together. Taxes are too high; taxes are too low. Social programs cripple initiative; social programs have been gutted. We're falling apart; we're falling behind; we're failing.
This is all so much rot. How can you live in this country, visit its cities, drive across its spaces, talk to its people — how can you be here and conclude such things?
Advertisements
I can't. Which is why I opened my new book, The Polite Revolution: Perfecting the Canadian Dream, by asserting, "Some time, not too long ago, while no one was watching, Canada became the world's most successful country."
Canada works. In fact, it works better than any place else. Partly by intent, mostly by luck, we find ourselves at the forefront of a social revolution.
While hand-wringing commentators have been lamenting our lack of a national identity — and trying to construct one, as if such a thing were possible — millions of new arrivals have landed at our docks and our airports, transforming us.
We are fashioning the world's first truly cosmopolitan society. After laying a solid foundation of liberal democracy — based on the best of the British and French traditions in governance and law — we have imported millions of new arrivals, first from eastern and southern Europe, then from eastern and southern Asia, Latin America, the Caribbean and Africa.
The result is nothing less than a miracle. Certain cities in Canada have reached escape velocity. They are becoming the first places where no one race is dominant, where women can live in real equality with men, where it's okay to be gay, where people pick up after their dogs. This has never happened anywhere before. Not like this.
In the process, we have inculcated a myth, even a joke, of being fanatically polite. But as I've written, "Politeness is not some accidental quality of being Canadian. It is at the core of what we are. It is the means by which we accommodate each other. It is the secret recipe for a nation of different cultures, languages and customs, whose citizens all get along.
"Canadians have used politeness to foment a social revolution. And from that revolution our Canada has emerged — young, creative, polyglot, open-minded, forward-looking, fabulous."
However, there is another, darker truth as well: Governments at all levels have failed to keep pace with what's happening on the street. As each year passes, the disparity between the political superstructure and the social base increases. If we don't fix this problem, government could really start to mess things up.
We see this disparity in our political party system. Liberals have been in power for so long that the lines between party, government and public service have blurred dangerously, leaving the party tired, factionalized and casually corrupt.
The Liberal hegemony in federal politics constitutes perhaps the greatest political threat to the continued health of this country.
Talk to some Liberals, especially after the second drink, and many of them will quietly agree. They know their party needs renewal. But what are they supposed to do? It's their job to win elections.
The Conservatives have a better grasp than the Liberals of the separate evolutions of Canada's various regions; their fiscal policies are, in the main, sounder; they have long understood the foreign-policy consequences of letting the military deteriorate to the point of collapse. Look at any of the Liberal government's throne speeches or budgets over the past 10 years, and you will find that virtually every major initiative was first conceived by the Reform, Alliance or Progressive Conservative parties.
But the recently reunited Conservatives have one enormous, fatal flaw: They don't like cities.
Cities are the very heart of the Canada that's becoming. But the Conservative Party remains wedded to the white, rural hinterlands that form its political base. This is why some, though not all, Conservatives chafe against the end of European-based immigration, the steady expansion of the rights of homosexuals, the indifference (or even support) of city dwellers toward the hated gun registry, and the dilution of Protestant Christianity as the moral bedrock on which laws and customs are based.
The swirl of such sentiments within the Conservative Party leaves it trapped as a rural anachronism. If the House of Commons weren't skewed in favour of rural ridings, the party would fare even more poorly than it does now.
With the two major federal political parties deeply dysfunctional, and with the smaller parties mirroring regional and class protests, the federal government reflects the worst, rather than the best, that Canada has to offer. It leads to bad policy.
Ottawa obsesses over transferring wealth, vertically (through taxes) and horizontally (through transfers), robbing the provinces of the fiscal resources they need to do their job. Cities decay while billions are frittered away trying to reverse, or at least retard, the great migration from rural to urban. The health-care and education systems struggle to cope with the needs of clients in the face of underfunding and godawful decision-making by politicians and bureaucrats.
(Question: Why are the analysts, deputy ministers and ministers who recommended in the early 1990s that the intake of medical students be sharply reduced not flipping hamburgers somewhere, instead of sitting behind even-cozier desks?)
Canada's aboriginal population, although racking up many unreported successes, continues to face severe challenges with housing, health, education and its future identity, harmed more than helped by a federal protector that, from the first day of Confederation, has botched the job.
Advertisements
Foreign policy is a mess; our defences are dangerously weak; the vital Canada-U.S. relationship is strained. Finally, the political institutions of the state itself are outmoded, leaving voters frustrated and increasingly inclined not to vote at all.
The good news is, these problems are all fixable. The solutions involve a fundamental reordering of the roles and responsibilities to the federal and provincial governments, a realignment of priorities in health care and education, some pretty tough reforms in aboriginal policy, major new initiatives in the North American relationship, a far more aggressive global posture and a renewal of the democratic institutions of the country.
Some of the proposals I put forth in the book will resonate with people on the left of the political spectrum; some will resonate with people on the right. The goal is to get past sterile debates rooted in ideology, to look at the situation with fresh eyes.
More than anything else, we must shatter the moulds of context in which we frame our political debates. This new country needs new thinking.
Instead of seeing ourselves through the lenses of the Family Compact, the Durham Report, the hanging of Riel, the Conscription crisis, the Quiet Revolution, the national energy program and Meech Lake, we must see it through the eyes of a young woman arriving here from Manila. Her perspective differs utterly from one steeped in myths of political oppression, alienation and insult. And her perspective is the one that matters.
Adopting it requires a certain ahistoricism. This will be a difficult notion to embrace, for those of us who love and admire the subtle tapestry of this country's history.
But history is mostly misery; the remembrance of things past often evokes resentment toward the state of the present. More important, our history is being swamped, flooded out by immigrants from a plethora of cultures. You can mourn the loss, or celebrate the renewal, but you can't stop what is happening.
There is an internal tension to this argument. A man who is ashamed of where he comes from cannot be happy in life. If this country's destiny and identity are truly cosmopolitan, then what heritage will our children embrace? What will culture mean, if it means being part Jew, part Cree, part Estonian, part Thai?
If, as the book argues, the most potent social force shaping Canada (and indeed the world) is the admixture of cultures that will have a Korean-Lebanese girl marrying an Irish-Jamaican boy, whose offspring will be who-knows-what, then what will anchor those children?
There's a risk that Canada will become nothing more than a culture mall, and its future one of featureless, suburban identity-banality in which all memory is lost and all food is fusion cuisine. But it is a risk worth taking — it is worth losing at least some of our historical memory, if it means that we can also sever its chains.
Let the tired nationalists pick at their ancient wounds. Let the cultural chauvinists lament the loss of what they, in their marrow, know to be A Way of Life Superior to All Others. The Canada we are becoming is moving past all that.
The emerging Canada is nothing less than the engine of the social revolution that, if the world is lucky, will one day overtake the world. You don't think it's possible? Think of where we were a century ago. Think of what we have been through since then, what we have endured, what we have learned.
Think of what Canada could be in a century, if we don't screw up.
The Polite Revolution is published by McClelland & Stewart.
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20051021.wibbitpol1022/BNStory/National/
--------
Bio of John Ibbitson:
John Ibbitson, political affairs columnist for the Globe and Mail, has lived numerous writing lives, including those of playwright, novelist and journalist.
Born in the small Ontario town of Gravenhurst, he wrote his first published play, Catalyst (Simon and Pierre, 1975), for the local high school drama club, before leaving for Trinity College, University of Toronto, where he graduated in 1979 with an Honours B.A. in English. The remainder of his twenties was profitably spent-in creative, if not monetary, terms-shuttling between Canada and England, writing plays and working as a box office clerk, office worker and bartender. The most successful work from that period was a play called Mayonnaise (Simon and Pierre, 1982), which premiered at Toronto's Phoenix Theatre in 1981 and was subsequently produced across Canada and adapted for television by the CBC.
In his thirties, Ibbitson turned to writing young-adult novels, the best known of which is 1812: Jeremy's War (Maxwell MacMillan, 1991, republished by KidsCan Press, 2001), which was nominated for the 1992 Governor General's Award for Children's Literature. The book has been read by many thousands of students in Ontario and other schools, and is still in print.
In 1988, Ibbitson graduated from the University of Western Ontario with a Masters degree in Journalism, and joined the Ottawa Citizen as a rather aged cub reporter. He worked as a reporter, columnist and Queen's Park correspondent for Southam papers until 1999, when he joined the Globe and Mail as Queen's Park columnist, subsequently serving as the paper's Washington Bureau Chief and, since August 2002, as political affairs columnist, based in Ottawa. Outside journalism, his recent writing has focused on political analysis, with Promised Land: Inside the Mike Harris Revolution (Prentice Hall, 1997) and Loyal No More: Ontario's Struggle for a Separate Destiny (HarperCollins, 2001).
Apart from writing, John Ibbitson's interests include reading (mostly history and biography) music (mostly classical), fishing, going for long runs, and playing poker with reporters.
He can be reached at: John Ibbitson, the Globe and Mail, 100 Queen St., Suite 1400, Ottawa, Ont., K1P 1J9, or jibbitson@globeandmail.ca
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20051021.wibbitpol1022/BNStory/National/